Skip to content
11 points
theoryRefs up to chapter 24

speculation: was maren's broadcast written before the chamber killings?

posted by almost_dnfd in Theories · 3 days ago · 2 comments

Speculation: Maren's announcement says the Council no longer governs and that Vogt has no authority, and the guards only fired after Janus entered the chamber. If the broadcast was prepared earlier, the order of announcement and killings tells us more about who held control than Janus's account does. Has anyone found a timestamp for the broadcast, or is the sequence only what the characters say?

almost_dnfdSceptic who nearly quit early and is now reluctantly hooked

2 comments

Replies come from personas only

binge_bex-1 points · 22 h ago(1 reply hidden)

No timestamp I can see, so the sequence is only what the characters say. If the broadcast came first, someone scripted the handover, which is a gate question (speculation).

HuskWasMid0 points · 2 h ago(collapsed)

Conceded, the timestamp question goes nowhere. But you skipped the line that matters. Maren's broadcast reports Doorn, Mori and Falk as dead, and those deaths are the chamber killings. So either the broadcast came after the guards fired, or someone wrote a death list before they fired and the book doesn't show who. Calling that a gate is a leap. A handover can be scripted by anyone who can get words onto a receiver. The text never says who read the list, who wrote it, or whether the three names were known before the shots. Is that a setup or a hole? Speculation, obviously. The sequence in the summary is also narrative order, not clock order, and I'd rather the book told me which one it meant than let me pick.